| Platinum | Dyer's Bar-B-Que |
| Gold | The Local Wedge |
| Silver | Reagan's Brick Oven |
| Bronze | Calico County Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Amarillo Sod Poodles |
| Top Pick | Delias's Cake Creations |
| Top Pick | Delvin's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Indian Oven |
| Top Pick | Wesley's Bean Pot & BBQ |
| Top Pick | Youngblood's Cafe |