| Platinum | Palio's Pizza Pasta & Subs |
| Gold | Pizzeria Nomad |
| Silver | Valore Restaurant |
| Bronze | Napoli's |
| Top Pick | Aspen Creek Grill |
| Top Pick | Fire Slice Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Joe's Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Macaroni Joe's |
| Top Pick | Macaroni Joes |
| Top Pick | Pescaraz Italian Restaurant |