| Platinum | 575 Pizzeria |
| Gold | Pizza Planet |
| Silver | Giovanni's Pizza & Calzone |
| Bronze | La Bella Pizza |
| Top Pick | Big Jim's Pizza Co |
| Top Pick | Fire Slice Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Palio's Pizza Pasta & Subs |
| Top Pick | Pescaraz Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pizzeria Nomad |
| Top Pick | Reagan's Brick Oven |