| Platinum | Good Intentions Metaphysical |
| Platinum | KMC Jewelers |
| Gold | Abbie's Accessories |
| Silver | 6th Street Antique Mall (Real Antique Store) |
| Bronze | Shannon's Glits and Glam |
| Top Pick | Goodin's Jewelry |
| Top Pick | Graham Brothers Jewelers LP |
| Top Pick | Jewelry Doctors |
| Top Pick | Mind of Mo |